Friday, October 1, 2021

One-armed semi-pro player

 George Ely was a star California semi-pro second baseman and pitcher from about 1907 to 1912. He lost his right arm when he fell between the wheels of a dray (a cart) when he was either three or ten years old. Newspaper articles differ on both his age at the time of the accident and which arm he lost. Pictures make it clear that he lost his right arm.


It seems that he was a very good player. In 1907 Judge McCredie, manager of Portland in the Pacific Coast League, took the day off for a scouting trip. He watched a game between Santa Ana and Santa Monica. Ely attracted McCredie's attention, but his handicap kept McCredie from giving a definite offer. Ely was 18 then. He hit .321 for Maier in the California Winter League in the winter of 1908-09, and was thought highly of by Coast League players and officials, but again it seems that his lack of a right arm kept from a professional contract. 

He was known for his great fielding and heavy hitting, and I think it's clear that he was a very good player. California had a very good semi-pro scene then. 

He worked in a telegraph office at a Salt Lake Railroad depot during his career, and was still there in 1918, the last mention I've seen of him.

Career:

Year        Team            League                             Notes
1905       Los Angeles High School
1908       Salt Lake      Pacific League
1908-09 Maier            California Winter League  Hit .321
1908-09 Edisons         California Winter League
1909      Caldwell        Idaho State League
1909      Gardena         Southern State League
1910      Dyas-Cline
1911      Hoegees
1912      Venice


Sources:

3 comments:

  1. I actually had never heard of him before. I had heard of a good many other one armed minor leaguers and MLB players, and the fact that these guys could work without an arm is amazing. Nowadays, most teams would probably take one look at a one armed player and refuse him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'd never heard of him before either. I was looking through some old newspapers when I stumbled upon mention of the "one-armed wonder" and had to check it out. As far as I know, nobody's written about him before.

      As an update, I believe I find his gravestone online. If it is, he was George A. Ely and he lived 1888-1967.

      Delete
  2. Your title made me kind of nervous, as I've slowly been working on a post about a one-armed player, and was hoping that you hadn't beat me to him. Thankfully my guy and your guy aren't one in the same. Who knew that were so many one-armed players?

    ReplyDelete

These are the saddest of possible words: Romero to Kittredge to Helsley

 On April 24 the Cardinals led the Diamond Backs 3-1 after six good innings from starter Kyle Gibson. After that, JoJo Romero threw a scorel...